Showing posts with label Billy Crudup. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Billy Crudup. Show all posts

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Public Enemies: Once Again, Gangsters With a Heart

Released as the summer’s high-brow alternative to dumbass comedies such as Year One and kiddy blockbusters like Transformers, Michael Mann’s Public Enemies makes a valiant attempt to deliver first-class entertainment to the content-starved summer moviegoer. Even though I think it largely falls short of that goal, it’s worth keeping on your radar for a future DVD release.

The film boasts an array of talented stars giving studiously crafted performances - Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, Marion Cotillard, Billy Crudup, Stephen Dorff, Giovanni Ribisi, Lili Taylor. The story works valiantly to create a Screnwriting-text approved plot, with nice parallelism being John Dillinger (Depp) and his criminal buddies and special Agent Melvin Purvis (Bale) and his boss J. Edgar Hoover (Crudup), who share more than a love of adventure, need for public adoration, and grandiose self-image with their criminal counterparts as Hoover‘s G-Men attempt to round up the annoying bank robbers who, along with their organized crime buddies, seem to be the only high-rollers around during the bleak 1930‘s. And the direction focuses in on key moments - a casual arrest at the Motel Congress in Tucson or a protracted shoot-out at a Wisconsin motel - to delve deeper into the tensions and tribulations of the warring parties. So there's a lot going for this film, and I was rooting for it to deliver.

And the movie certainly wants to be taken seriously. Public Enemies relies heavily on the first word in its title for its theme. The first bank robbery we see, Dillinger leaves the customer’s money and rides away from the robbery with a bevy of hostages who are more titillated by the adventure than scared. He’s a robber who’s more concerned with maintaining his popular public image than with increasing his profit margins. Yet have no illusions: this Robin Hood robs from the rich and keeps it for himself. When he begins an affair with the pure-hearted-but-spunky coat-check girl (Cotillard), you know that it’s his heart that will ultimately get him in trouble.

The same applies for Bale’s Purvis, a can-do field agent who we first see chasing down Pretty Boy Floyd through the woods of Indiana. Purvis gets his man, and does it with no nonsense; yet his boss, J. Edgar, rivals Dillinger for his love of the public spotlight, which can leave Purvis feeling, at times, compromised. And even if Purvis is fearless for his own safety, he will hesitate, it seems, when it comes to the life of his men.

Which of these two - Dillinger or Purvis - will overcome their Achilles heel first to out-tough the other is something of a predetermined question, if we know anything at all about history. So the enjoyment in this film needs to be in the ride of how we get there, and what we learn along the way. The best thing going here is the art direction, which re-creates 1930's culture with such assiduous and continuously enjoyable detail: whether it be the keystone-cops quality to the armed infantrymen guarding Dillinger’s cell or the tins of tuna that supply Dillinger’s sojourns in safe-houses in rural Indiana, the atmosphere of the film is deliciously authentic, and adds to right touch of brightness and macho posturing to the perilous sensibility of the 1930's. The film is at it's best when it's visually explaining the contradictions of this time: the descent of decent folk into an era of poverty and spectacular criminality, all while preserving a veneer of civilization. Incidental radio programs of citizens complaining of ineffectual government; the delicious thrill of Hoover’s Movietones asking the cinema audience to obliviously “look left” and “look right” to spot the “most wanted” even while Dillinger is sitting, hiding in plain view in their midst.

Yet despite all the promise, some mysterious ingredient never quite catches hold, and the film never becomes more than the sum of its parts. Certainly part of this may simply be that the loveable gangster meme has been pretty well exhausted in popular culture. From Bonnie and Clyde through to the Sopranos, there’s rather little new here in portrayal of John Dillinger as a raffish criminal touched with bouts of charity and sentimentality, and whose fate as the country‘s most notorious criminal is destined to catch up to him. Even with great performance, fascinating art direction, and a competent screenplay, there’re too many saggy sections of the film, which could have been trimmed by at least twenty minutes.

For all the firearms and fuss, we get barely more insight into what makes Dillinger tick than a short scene where he walks unnoticed into the very FBI office that’s tracking him, looking at the FBI stakeout pictures of himself while he goes unnoticed to the Feds in the room. The irony here is delicious, but preciously thin for a movie that asks us to take it so seriously.

The movie may be worth a go - especially in the waning days of summer when there's precious little else of substance - but ultimately, who Dillinger is and why he’s driven to the limelight remains at least as mysterious as, say, our own celebrity contemporaries, and what we end up learning about him pales in comparison to what we already know about our own public oddities: like, for instance, Michael Jackson.

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Watchmen: Sci-Fi Meets Ramond Chandler In Dali-eque Melange

There is a lot to say about Zack Snyder's (300) just released Watchmen, based on the 1985 graphic novel by Alan Moore (who also penned "V for Vendetta" and is widely credited for birthing the "dark" side of modern comics.) Not having read the original comic novel, however, I cannot say whether it is better, or worse, a travesty or a marvel of audaciousness. However, I do know that there is a tense relationship between the two, which seems to have affected how this movie has turned out. And so I will tell you that this is quite an original movie that at well over two and a half hours is, sadly, too long, too distanced, and a bit too tedious to really have the impact that I think this unique film deserved.

Firstly, if these Watchmen are also meant to be watch men - makers of clocks and watchers of human destiny and time - then the types of watches dealt with here are more the melted clocks of Salvador Dali than the neatly backward-ticking timepieces in a movie such as Benjamin Button. And I appreciate that. I like a movie that's willing to play with narrative and that travels in alternate realities. Snyder here has chosen to keep the movie set in Moore's original mid-eighties milieux as its base time frame of reference, which itself is a parallel 1980's to the real one (Richard Nixon is still President, somehow having repealed the Twenty-Second Amendment - and avoided Watergate - to be enjoying his fifth term). However, I think this decision to freeze the story in its original time may have been a mistake (I'll get to this more later) though I can appreciate how hard the pressure must have been not to tamper too much with what many fans must consider Moore's Bible. But I think that had the movie updated the base timeline to present day, many of its themes and obsessions would have held more resonance. But more on that in a bit.

It is perhaps unfair to criticize a movie based on Moore's graphic novel as being cliche - since it is Moore's story itself that lies as the inspiration for later films such as The Dark Knight, The Incredibles, Hancock, Sky Captain, and even perhaps some twists and turns of X-Men. But the film does travel territory that we have been down now quite a few times before: the down-and-out superhero, the quandary of superhuman power given to mortal hearts, the dynamics of a group of heroes whose vigilante actions are questionable, to say the least, and whose loyalties hang together through nothing more than their common obsessions and enemies. Watchmen perhaps originated many of these tropes, and unfortunately, Snyder isn't able to update them quite enough to be fresh again: though in Watchmen, perhaps more than most other films of this type (with the exception, of course of V for Vendetta), the society in which the superheros skulk is blacker than even our Dark Knights, and so their actions do take on the kind of heroic cynicism that have fascinated male teenagers for generations.

What is original about Watchmen is that unlike X-Men, where ability IS character, in this movie, it is the reverse: character - as it is slowly revealed in the film - IS the super ability. And so we don't quite know what superpowers these watchmen are capable of until we learn who they are, how they came to be, and who they imagine themselves becoming. The characters in this story are revealed through a Raymond Chanlder-esque detective frame, so what we have here is a mystery in which, over two-and-a-half hours, the viewer learns what powers our heroes possess. All this is very rich and textual, and the abilities of the various characters - the Comedian, Dr. Manhattan, Rorschach - slowly come into focus as we realize that each represents a kind of position on the moral continuum.

My favorite, and the audience's as well, I suspect, is Rorschach, our narrator, a masked man with disturbingly moving blots rather than features, who is revealed to have a clear, uncompromising moral judgement of the "scum" littering the city streets, and who prizes this moral certitude above all else: Robert de Niro's taxi driver in Taxi given mystical abilities. Inhabiting the opposite end of the moral spectrum is another Watchman, the intellectually superior Adrien Veidt (a.k.a. Ozymandias), whose ability to reach moral compromise in his quest to establish a greater good is, shall we say, superbly dramatic. Inhabiting the middle ground between the two is Night Owl (or the second Night Owl, as this story spans two generations of Watchmen), the most human of the watchmen and the most humane; he needs the aid of his technological devices to see through the darkness more clearly - and he knows also that it is his judgement the others prize as representing the heart of the group.

Circling these three are three other Watchmen: The Comedian, who's violently ironic comic detachment from life seems to be the initiator of many of the parallel stories herein; Dr. Manhattan, a glowing blue superhuman who, shall we merely say here, is detached from the living for entirely different reasons. And Laurie Jupiter (a.k.a. Silk Spectre II), who, I'm sad to say, seems to merely be the kick-ass babe the boys want to drool over. Why the women in this movie aren't given the same level of symbolic import as the men is, indeed, one of the ways in which this film squanders its potential.

Then there are the EARLIER generation of Watchmen to consider, some of which seem to have aged and some of which haven't, as well as a barely touched upon assortment of villains, girlfriends, colleagues, "real life" people, and other hangers on. All of which are entirely too much for a story that needs to get in and get out from an emotional core that is already distanced from us by that syrupy Raymond Chanlder-esque narration. Say what you want about Bryan Singer, but at least that guy knows how to craft a group of diverse, assorted characters around a single, centrally involving concept that they all must circle (think "who is Keyser Soze?"). The problem for Snyder is that he's lost himself to the Watchmen serial and the multiple parallel story lines without being able to pull from it a guiding central premise for the film.

That he seems to come up with one at the end is nice: the visual coda with Rorschach especially so. I just wish he had pulled that thread sooner, and trimmed out some of the unnecessary characters and fat.

And, back to my beginning comment, I also think updating the film to present day would have had even more impact. First, with the way time is shifted here, I am continually asking myself why we keep coming back to 1985. Why is that time the present? It was for Moore because when he wrote the Watchmen comics, it was the present, and this was a critique of Reganite culture - of the moment he was living in. Moore's story was written in the alternative present because it meant to be very contemporary: a comment on the cold war, an alternate version of the present, not the past. Perhaps Snyder felt that 1985 could stand in for 2005, Regan/Nixon standing in for Bush, Afghanistan (the first war) standing in for Iraq, without needing an update. But 2005 now too is already past (we're now dramatically in Obama's 2009 - a problem of historicity that a movie, which takes years to make, has to deal with more than a comic novel, which takes mere weeks to produce). And so, sadly, the central worry of the film (cold war standoff) feels out of date. And having an alternative past to our present moment feels like a betrayal of what Moore was up to, and the "real people" referenced in the film now feel entirely out of place. We are watching now not a critique of our culture but a critique of a history we no longer feel much worry or concern about.

And yet the film's dark vision and cynical view of realpolitik couldn't be more relevant. Shifting events in the story to Iraq, Pakistan, Bush I/II and terrorism rather than Vietnam and Afghanistan and cold war I believe would have spoken to the fears of OUR time and I think would have given the film the immediate emotional punch that it needed. For that was what Moore was going for originally, and by slavishly sticking to that historical element Snyder has drained all feeling from the movie, leaving us with something historical and clinical rather than immediate and meaningful.

There's also an issue of tone, which I don't think Snyder has gotten quite right. An example would be the real people: Nixon, Pat Buchanan, etc. They are caricatures of their real-life counterparts, yet they are neither extremely caricatured, nor are they at all similar. Rather, it was as if Snyder had pulled people off the street of the approximate gender and age of those people and told them to try and sound a little like them (perhaps never even having heard them). All this creates a kind of reality that is neither here nor there, when I think Snyder needed a reality that was most definitely somewhere: placed, perhaps, in an even more heightened alternative, and carrying us through to the world we recognize, or maybe barely recognize, today. George Stephanopolous, say, and an even more clown-mirror distorted version of him, rather than a stand-up comedian's version of McLaughlin Group.

Instead, it seems that Snyder was going for an interpretation, rather than a reinterpretation, of Moore: a loving introduction to the works of the maestro. And because this material really is subversive, what he's produced is a highly suggestive film that works backwards to introduce characters (intuitively rather than deductively), that wows us with transportation between time and place and suggestive images of war and murder that are both beautiful and disturbing (Snyder brings his 300 talents to this film, and it looks fantastic), that deals with the big themes of life and death, humanity and science, will and destiny, cynicism and belief. It is a movie that I have a hard time forgetting, and yet at times bored me to tears, and that I fear I may have made sound much more interesting than it is.

All of which is to say, it is a great film hampered by some very basic storytelling flaws: lack of focus, too much emotional distance, not enough risk-taking in digesting the source and giving us back something that captures the spirit more than the word of the original.

I really wish it had been better. A clear and moving deconstruction of our present political situation is highly called for, and the sci-fi / Chandler treatment of our particular moment on the brink of destruction, which is what's promised in the Watchmen vision, could have been fantastic. But as Don Rumsfeld used to say, sometimes you go to watch the movie you have, not the movie you might like to have.

Now if only Snyder had had the audacity to have quoted Rumsfeld, he really would have been on to something.